Welcome back to Tony Talk, a column in which Gold Derby contributors Sam Eckmann and David Buchanan offer Tony Awards analysis. The fall season on Broadway continues apace with more play and play revival openings, and we reconvene to discuss Lincoln Center Theater’s newest production.
David Buchanan: Sam, we are back to discuss yet another star-studded play revival this Broadway season: A Few Good Men, which opened at Lincoln Center on Oct. 29. This production has been highly anticipated for a several compelling reasons. It marks the first Broadway revival of the work that really put Aaron Sorkin on the map. It’s also a rare turn to directing a drama for musical theater superstar Michael Arden. And Bradley Whitford has stepped into the iconic role of Lt. Col. Jessup, played on stage by the late Stephen Lang and immortalized in Rob Reiner’s film by Jack Nicholson. Whitford, a frequent Sorkin collaborator, made his Broadway debut in the original 1989 production.
I want to start by discussing Arden, not only because of the incredible run he’s been on this past decade with Spring Awakening, Once On This Island, A Christmas Carol, Parade, Maybe Happy Ending, and The Lost Boys, but also his bold decision to stage this show in a house as large as the Vivian Beaumont Theater. Certainly the scope of the play and its moral implications command a big venue, and I found many of the tentpole scenes quite thrilling. The sound of those Marines responding to orders from 1st Lt. Kendrick, for example, filled the space sonically as powerfully as in any musical I’ve seen there.
A Few Good Men could mark Arden’s first-ever Tony nomination for a play. His 10 previous Tony nominations — and six wins — have come for work on musicals and musical revivals. Do you think he did enough with the cavernous Vivian Beaumont stage and with Sorkin’s idealistic material to warrant one of the five Best Director spots in a season that will feature at least 20 plays and play revivals?

Sam Eckmann: I have to admit, I let out a sigh of relief when I sat down and took in the gargantuan military base set crafted by Arden’s frequent collaborator and two-time Tony winner Dane Laffrey. The Vivian Beaumont has the deepest playing space on Broadway, with a three-quarter thrust stage that extends beyond the proscenium and into the audience. Plenty of productions in this venue fail to take advantage of the opportunities this unique stage provides, but Arden utilizes every inch of it.
The stage extends all the way to the upstage wall, which contains an immense moving hangar door that provides the backdrop for a brilliantly lit tableau. Metal support columns line the sides of the stage, creating a cavernous effect that lets the audience get lost in the space. There’s even a security tower hovering over stage left. Arden fills the space with actors dressed as military personnel going about their day-to-day duties, so the setting feels alive. He even takes the classic Sorkin “walk and talk” technique and translates it to the stage. The production feels grand and “full,” which is honestly quite rare for a Broadway play these days.
Does all this translate into a Tony nomination for Arden? That’s harder to say. The only other play Arden has directed on Broadway is A Christmas Carol. I thought his work was more than worthy of a nomination for that magic-box production, but Tony nominators didn’t go for it. Then again, nominators never go for holiday fare in this director category, so this one example doesn’t serve as a great barometer for Arden’s Tony chances this year.
Instead, I think his main hurdle is that A Few Good Men will end its run in January in order to make room for Lincoln Center Theater’s The Sound of Music revival. The spring will bring in a host of new plays that will be more fresh in nominators’ minds as they cast their ballots. So a majority of nomination slots could be scooped up by late-breaking work from the likes of Diane Paulus (Rhinoceros), Joe Mantello (Small Mouth Sounds), Evan Cabnet (Gloria), Thomas Kail (The Odd Couple), and more.
Still, I think Arden’s successful use of space, his ability to create a living world on stage, and the dynamics he achieves between his actors will keep him in the conversation for a nomination. Not to mention that the central court case, which essentially takes up all of Act 2, is so thrillingly paced that the audience can barely breathe until the final verdict comes down. He ticks off a lot of boxes as far as a directing nominee goes.
You mentioned some of the actors before, and I’d love to hear who you thought were standouts. They all have the unenviable task of being compared to their infamous film counterparts. Who do you believe can snatch a Tony nomination from this cast?

Buchanan: I would also single out five-time Tony nominee Japhy Weideman’s lighting design. It is not particularly flashy, but it does a tremendous amount of the heavy lifting of transforming the huge hangar-like playing space into myriad, more intimate rooms by cordoning off sections of the stage in slanted rectangles and squares of light. He truly knows how to focus the audience’s eye on the action.
To answer your question about the performers, I’m sure the one everyone’s most curious about must be Whitford, not only because it is his first Broadway role in nearly two decades, but also because he has to differentiate himself from Nicholson’s performance and indelible reading of the film’s most famous line, “You can’t handle the truth!”
I’m very pleased to say that Whitford accomplishes the latter task, delivering it in a way that’s distinct from the three-time Oscar winner; he gives it even more of a bellow and really elongates the vowel in “truth” to very strong effect. I found him equally good later in that same scene as he suffers the consequences of what he admits on the stand.
But I’m wondering if there’s enough meat on the bones of this role to earn him a Tony nomination, especially in another Broadway season overcrowded with plays and play revivals. Yes, as the show’s main antagonist, he has two or three scenes where Jessup flares with arrogance, misogyny, homophobia, and other detestable attributes, but Whitford brings a lot of inner fury to the role and might not show enough fieriness to break through in a field of only five. The original production notably didn’t net Lang a nomination, as its sole bid went to Tom Hulce as Daniel Kaffee, played this time by Tom Blyth.
For his Broadway debut, Blyth could get nominated for Best Actor. From his very first scene, he’s convincingly all American and affable, but the effectiveness of his performance lies in how much he makes us see Kaffee evolve in real time on the stage. Case in point, he really delivers in that dynamite scene he has after a setback in court, in which he gets drunk and then very introspectively talks about his father. He also has ample amounts of charisma and swagger in the courtroom scenes, which should be endearing to Tony nominators. Even so, we have a very competitive slate of performers in Best Actor in a Play this season, including Billy Crystal, Bill Irwin, Tom Hiddleston, Ruben Santiago-Hudson, Jonathan Groff, Tony Shalhoub, and more, so we’ll have to see how the spring unfolds.
And although a nomination is unlikely given that Whitford has the flashier role, I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention Broadway mainstay Thom Sesma as Captain Markinson. From his very first scene, he has exactly the right gravitas for the serious stakes of the show, and he’s at the center of one of the most moving stage pictures in the production, which I won’t spoil. Suffice it to say, his character demonstrates as much moral rectitude and clarity as anyone on that stage, and he plays it with moving conviction without ever pushing. It’s a lovely featured performance.
How do you assess these gentlemen’s chances, as well as Krysta Rodriguez’s as Galloway, the internal affairs attorney who relentlessly pursues the case and believes in her clients’ innocence? Depending on how you think the performers, director, and designers will fare, how much of a factor will the show overall be in the Best Play Revival category?

Eckmann: Interesting that you mention Sesma as another standout supporting player, because I also found plenty to love among all the featured performers. Broadway mainstay Nick Blaemire and past Tony nominee Michael Oberholtzer make meals out of small roles. But I would argue that Lavel Schley has the greatest emotional impact in the supporting cast. In his Broadway debut, Schley portrays Harold W. Dawson, one of the two Marines standing trial. The character’s military pride and moral fortitude are put to the test, as his very strength of character might be what gets him convicted. Schley displays this inner conflict with a quiet intensity that ripped at my heart and stayed with me well after the performance ended.
So here is the quandary: Whitford obviously has the biggest, most fiery role of any of the eligible featured actors in the production. And returning to the stage in the play that gave him his Broadway debut certainly gives him the most compelling awards narrative of the cast. But as you mention, Jessup only has a few scenes, and we’ve both mentioned other supporting actors who might also have support. If nominators are not united behind a single featured actor candidate, the show risks not landing a nominee in that category altogether.
Rodriguez’s chances will depend on which acting category she is ultimately eligible for. One could make the argument for lead actress as she certainly has more stage time than Whitford and drives the plot forward in a major way. You could also argue for featured actress since she doesn’t steer the narrative quite as much in Act 2, where Blyth truly takes center stage as the lead.
Personally, I think she has a stronger chance in the featured race, due to the fact that her best scenes are those where she could bounce energy off her costars amid Sorkin’s rapid-fire dialogue, ratcheting up tension or creating a moment of levity. That skill is a hallmark of many featured acting nominees, whereas a performer often needs to dominate their play to be competitive for lead actress. The Tony Administration Committee should be meeting by the end of the month to deliver their first round of eligibility decisions, so hopefully we will have our answer in the coming weeks.
Sorkin has also talked about revising his earlier script. If the committee decides the revisions make it eligible as a new play, Sorkin could be eligible for a writing nomination. In recent years, an author’s inclusion here has greatly helped a revival’s chances when it comes to snagging a nomination. There are still a few plays that are awaiting an official “new” or “revival” classification for the Tony Awards, but there’s no denying that this season is heavy with re-examinations of classic works, making Best Revival of a Play arguably the most competitive of the four “best in show” categories. Sorkin’s name might give A Few Good Men a bit of extra heft, but in an extremely competitive field the production might have to settle for some below-the-line nominations but a miss n the top category.
Buchanan: Excellent point about whether or not Sorkin will appear on the ballot. It could help the show in the most crowded production contest of the season, though the Oscar- and Emmy-winning writer has never once been nominated for a Tony. Looking back at last year’s Best Play Revival line-up, the nominators clearly preferred radical reinterpretations of classic works (Death of a Salesman, Oedipus), first-time Broadway mountings of established plays (Becky Shaw, Every Brilliant Thing), or totally raved-about productions (Fallen Angels).
I don’t think A Few Good Men hits any of those criteria straight-on, so again we’ll have to see how the rest of the field takes shape before we can confidently assess its chances.

