Inherent to the idea of making a feature film about the story of Sylvester Stallone‘s unlikely rise to superstardom by writing and filming Rocky is one serious casting challenge. Who could possibly play Sylvester Stallone? Because while every dude bro can shout “Adrian!” with a baritone affect, it was going to take a careful balance to not just invoke the iconic screen presence, but to do so in a performance emotionally honest enough to carry a feel-good crowd pleaser.
But after two-time Oscar winner Peter Farrelly signed on to direct I Play Rocky and turned to his go-to casting director with the task, Rick Montgomery knew he would be able to do it. “I knew it was going to be tough, but a casting director never thinks that they can’t do it,” he told Gold Derby. “They’re going to make this movie, so you’re going to find it. Because you have to find it.”
Montgomery’s time on I Play Rocky began about a year before production with a simple directive from Farrelly: “Go find Stallone.” So the casting director — who previously worked with the director on Green Book, There’s Something About Mary, and Dumb and Dumber — got to work, getting Peter Gamble’s script out to agents and meeting with actors.
Meanwhile, across the country, Anthony Ippolito read about the project coming together and — being both a fan of Farrelly’s and familiar with the mythology behind Rocky‘s creation — decided to put himself on tape for the role. “I knew there was something really special that I would have loved to be a part of it,” Ippolito said. “But frankly, no one was asking me to audition for it.”
That audition, filmed in Ippolito’s grandmother’s basement for its ’70s aesthetic, eventually made its way to Montgomery. “I felt I was watching Sylvester Stallone as a young man,” Montgomery said. “It was that good from the get.”
From the perspective of a casting director, finding an actor to play Stallone was never going to be about looks or how well the performer could do the voice. “They might look like the character, but when words come out of their mouth, if you don’t believe what they’re saying, then it doesn’t matter how much they look like the person,” Montgomery said.
And he believed Ippolito.
“I called Pete, and just I said, ‘I got it. I I found the guy. I’m sending it to you. It’s gold,'” Montgomery recalled. “And he flipped right away.”
Essentially, it worked out just like Montgomery expected. They were making the movie, so he found the guy. And now that guy is predicted to get a Golden Globe nomination.
Golden Globes Film Nominations 2027
1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

11.

12.

13.

14.

15.

16.

17.

18.

19.

20.

21.

22.

23.

24.

25.


