Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson being sent home from Dancing With the Stars Season 35 on Tuesday night, just one week after Jenna Dewan and Val Chmerkovskiy were eliminated from the competition, feels like a pointed message: the fans are tired.
After weeks of downplaying their respective dance experiences — both Dewan and Shum Jr. were professional dancers before stepping into the world of acting and working on ABC properties like Grey’s Anatomy and The Rookie — things finally seemed to catch up to the stars and their married pros, signaling a fatigue over the state of the show. But is it that fans are over the people who come into the competition with a serious leg up, or is it that the fans are upset at Johnson and Chmerkovskiy being handed two sure-things?
It’s been brought up numerous times throughout the season, but Britt Stewart — a seven-season pro who has never won and has consistently been handed partners with low probabilities of going far — once shouted out Shum Jr. as a dream partner, only for the Glee alum to be paired up with Johnson, a two-time winner. Fans were up in arms over producers overlooking Stewart (who we should note is the only Black woman to be a pro on DWTS in the show’s 21-year history) and handing Shum Jr. — a competitor guaranteed to do well in the competition — to someone who has already won twice.
Similarly, fans were just as outraged at Dewan being partnered with Chmerkovskiy, who took second place just last season and has won three times with Rumer Willis, Laurie Hernandez, and Xochitl Gomez. That’s why, coming into this season, there seemed to be a serious anti-Chmerkovskiy and Johnson sentiment online, with some fans saying they are tired of these two getting what they see as preferential treatment.
Of course, there’s also the fact that halfway through the season, both teams were caught in a crisis over Chmerkovskiy posting a comment on social media that jokingly threatened violence against judge Carrie Ann Inaba. After Inaba criticised an illegal lift in Johnson’s choreography, leading to a tense moment between the two women, Chmerkovskiy took to Instagram to write, “You almost saw Fresh Prince enter the ballroom last night,” which many took as a reference to Will Smith slapping Chris Rock at the Oscars. After his comment, Chmerkovskiy was suspended from the show for one week, which resulted in Alan Bersten stepping in to dance with Jenna… who we might argue would have made a better partner from the start.

All of this is to say that there are numerous contributing factors to Dewan and Shum Jr. being sent home before the finale, but dance experience and pairings that seem to heavily favor two already well-established pros are ultimately going to be a lethal combination in this show. Who is to say if either contestant would have made it to the end had they been partnered with Stewart, Bersten, or any of the other professionals — it is possible that neither Dewan nor Shum Jr. connected with the fans in the way that Tatyana Ali or Connor Wood have — but it’s certainly worth asking how it got to this point in the first place.
At the end of the day, Dancing With the Stars is never going to have a cast list that utilizes celebs who have never had a day of dance experience in their life (it’s too impractical if you want actors, who often undergo even basic dance lessons for resume bolstering), but having not one, but two people who came into the show having made money as dancers in the past is just too much of a hurdle to overcome. It’s why the first thing that I thought after watching Dewan say her goodbyes was: I bet that Harry is next.
Dancing With the Stars is streaming on Disney+ and Hulu. The Season 35 finale airs live on Tuesday, November 24, at 8 p.m. ET/5 p.m. PT.
Disney+ offers a number of subscription options, so you can find the one that works for you. With ads, a subscription costs $12.49/month; without ads, it’s $21.49/month or $214.99/year.
There are also Disney+ bundles with Hulu, HBO Max, and ESPN+, so you can subscribe to up to three services at once and save over 40% every month. The bundles are available in a few different configurations, starting at $12.99/month for Disney+ and Hulu with ads, and going up to $34.99/month for Disney+, Hulu, and Max ad-free.
