In this year’s Grammy lineup for Best Musical Theater Album, two of the nominated projects feature individuals from behind the scenes who have previously won Emmys and Tonys. They are Lynn Ahrens, co-producer of the new Ragtime cast album, and Cinco Paul, songwriter and co-producer of the Schmigadoon! original Broadway cast recording.
If either of them wins the Grammy on Feb. 7, they’d be an Oscar away from achieving EGOT status.
In 1980, Ahrens won a Daytime Emmy in the category of Best Children’s Informational/Instructional Programming (Short Form) for H.E.L.P! — Dr. Henry’s Emergency Lessons for People. In 1998, she, along with Stephen Flaherty, won the Tony for Best Score for the original Broadway production of Ragtime. That same year, they also received a pair of Oscar nominations for the animated film musical Anastasia. They’ve been Grammy-nominated for Best Musical Theater Album three times before:
- In 1998 for the original studio cast recording of Ragtime; lost to Chicago
- In 2002 for the original cast album of Seussical; lost to The Producers
- In 2019 for the Broadway revival cast recording of Once on This Island, lost to The Band’s Visit
The most recent remounting of Ragtime did manage to win the Tony for Best Musical Revival over stiff competition from Cats: The Jellicle Ball this past year. Now, it’s looking to repeat the victory at the Grammys. If it does so, Ahrens better start getting more film work to complete her EGOT. Maybe it’s time for a Ragtime movie musical.
Meanwhile, Paul is halfway to EGOT thanks to Schmigadoon! alone. In 2022, he won a Primetime Emmy for Best Music & Lyrics for the song “Corn Puddin,'” from the first season of the original Apple TV series. In 2026, the Broadway adaptation won three Tonys for Paul: Best Musical (as a co-producer), Best Book of a Musical, and Best Original Score. The win for Best Original Score beat the presumed front-runner, Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York).
Paul is a previous Grammy nominee for Best Compilation Soundtrack for Visual Media for the first episode of Schmigadoon! in 2022. He ultimately came up short to The United States vs. Billie Holliday. Now, he’s hoping to do better this time as the mastermind behind the reigning Tony champ for Best Musical. If he wins, he’ll need to do more film work to complete his EGOT.
Musical Theater Album
1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

Two Strangers
Carry a Cake Across New York
According to Gold Derby’s combined predictions, Schmigadoon! has a 73% chance of winning Best Musical Theater Album, while Ragtime is in second place with 11% chance. Behind them are Chess, The Lost Boys, and Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York).

