This week on The Gilded Age, hell hath no fury like an Agnes van Rhijn scorned. We could all see it coming, something was off about Agnes’s interview with the Ladies Home Journal and the way she was approaching her role hosting President Grover Cleveland in a very old-fashioned way, and now, her worst nightmare is realized when Bertha Russell steals the gig out from under her. But before we get into Agnes’s worst nightmare (which is, in turn, some of Christine Baranski‘s best work), we must away to Newport.
When Peggy Scott became engaged last season to Dr. William Kirkland, it seemed like the engagement was a compromise, an acknowledgement that, despite the class differences that William’s mother has always been so quick to leverage against the Scotts, William was different and willing to put Peggy first. And yet… same shit, different season for ole Peggy. When the episode begins, William walks Peggy past a charming cottage in Newport, revealing to her utter surprise that it’s their new vacation home. William seems to not understand that Peggy is different from other women, which is why she’s more confused than excited when he’s like, “Here’s a whole house in Newport that I bought for us without telling you.” While Peggy is quick to thank William for this nice piece of real estate, but she’s also a little taken aback, and it’s the first of several red flags that will be popping up this week.
Peggy and William are in Newport for their wedding, and Marian, Ada, and Agnes are headed there for the occasion, too, assuming their new footman Oliver can handle getting their luggage into their carriage.

George Russell hasn’t been himself this season and last week we learned why – he’s picked up a laudanum addiction that has made him testy and belligerent, to the point where he is pushing away those closest to him and turning professional relationships with men he does business with, like J.D. Rockefeller, into liabilities that threaten his company. When he returned home to 61st street at the end of Episode 2 and found his way into Bertha’s bed, it seemed like a quiet cry for help as he nestled into her arms, admitting he feels lost, but this week he’s back to pushing her away. When he explains that the deal he’s trying to make with Rockefeller could make or break his business, Bertha offers to help, perhaps she could invite the Rockefellers for dinner, and George snaps. Where previously Bertha was an ally and an asset to him, he now seems disgusted by her, wincing at her every touch.

Over at the van Rhijn’s home — and by that, I mean Oscar and Enid van Rhijn — they’re preparing to host the first of their artist salons, this one in honor of painter William Merritt Chase. Oscar and Enid have the same goal in mind when it comes to these salons: becoming cool, hip influencers. They want to create a new class of society that cleans away the residue of the older generation… like Agnes, Lina Astor, and even Bertha Russell, none of whom are invited. Mamie Fish is the one person from the older, more stodgy generation who is invited, but that’s just because she’s an artist herself, and her medium is gossip. Oscar and Enid have invited Mamie knowing she’ll mention the salon to folks like Bertha to make them aware that they’re being left out of something special.
A quick sidebar to talk about Mamie Fish, the embodiment of chaotic neutral, always stirring the pot for her own delight? Though she’s always been a fixture on the show, it’s high time we call her out to appreciate the way she manages to maintain goodwill with everyone from all social groups, despite the fact that she’s a rumor-mongering butterfly who can stir up a whirlwind with the slightest bit of gossip. Ashlie Atkinson gets a minimal amount of screen time each week, but in her fairly brief appearances, she always leaves us delighting in the chaos she has created.

Agnes, meanwhile, is dealing with a blow to her ego when her Ladies Home Journal profile is published and is less than flattering, insinuating that she’s a little too old-fashioned to be hosting the President. She learns of the negative write-up while visiting Aurora Fane’s home in Newport and she is furious.

She vows to get her revenge by hosting the most polished Presidential dinner in history, declaring, “Vengeance shall be mine!” “Shouldn’t we leave vengeance to the Lord?” Ada asks, to which Agnes replies, “Not if we want it done properly. I find often the Lord is too lenient.” While Agnes vows vengeance in Newport, Bertha is up to her old double-crossing ways, convincing Mrs. Foster of the Heritage Society to allow her to host the President in her much larger, more modern home back in New York.
At Oscar and Enid’s salon, which features living art and a signature cocktail featuring Cointreau on ice, all the cool kids are there, including Jack Trotter, who was invited by Larry Russell. Jack is still self-conscious about his new clock-related wealth, but these days he can slurp oysters and eat artichokes with the best of them. At the salon, Carrie Astor introduces Jack to her cousin, Miss Summers, a young woman who is intrigued by Jack’s line of work as an inventor and impressed when he bids $1,000 on a still life he barely cares about just to get her attention. And Enid makes the mistake of introducing her husband Oscar to William Merritt Chase’s apprentice, Lee Klein, also a painter, who is intrigued by Oscar’s whole thing. The two flirt shamelessly and, oh, poor Enid. What has she done? She’s still foolishly trying to get her gay husband to sleep with her, but now here she’s gone and basically set him up with someone. Enid, I know you’re savvier than this!

Back in Newport, we come to learn that Elizabeth Kirkland is the type of mother who has exerted complete control over her son’s wedding. No surprise there. Even though Peggy is the bride, Elizabeth is the woman in charge. The day before the wedding, Peggy’s cousin arrives to announce that her singing group, the Fisk Jubilee Singers, will be performing at the wedding. This should be a big deal — based in Nashville, the Fisk Jubilee Singers have performed all over the world, including for Queen Victoria — but Elizabeth is displeased that a “traveling singing group will [be] screeching Negro spirituals” at the ceremony.

She’s even more displeased when Peggy’s parents Arthur and Dorothy offer Peggy and William their broom to jump over during their wedding. The Southern wedding tradition of jumping the broom was popular with enslaved people, which Arthur was, and Elizabeth wastes no time telling the Scotts that their contributions to the wedding are undignified, going so far as to allude to them as “reminders of darkness.” Elizabeth’s callous opinions and unwelcoming behavior cause a rift between her and William, so Peggy takes it upon herself to make things right with the Kirklands and force a compromise.
The day of the wedding, no one is sure if Elizabeth will actually show… until she arrives looking unhappy but unwilling to miss her only son’s big moment. Also attending the wedding is Dennis Haysbert, our first big guest star of the season. Haysbert plays Dr. Harris, a man who politely retrieves Ada’s purse from the floor when she drops it. Dr Harris was William’s professor at medical school, and Ada is not subtle about her instant attraction to him. The ceremony does indeed feature the Fisk singers and the jumping of the broom (maybe the first time ever that the show has filmed a shot in slow motion as Peggy and William jauntily float over the broom), and though Elizabeth looks mournful, for everyone else it’s a celebration.
When Marian, Ada, and Agnes return to New York, Agnes is greeted by an unwelcome letter from Mrs. Foster, explaining that Mrs. Russell is the new host of the Presidential dinner. Agnes unleashes in a way we’ve never seen before, her Biblical fury unfurling once again. “Mrs. Foster, who I now consider a Judas, has allowed Mrs. George Russell to steal the Presidential dinner away from me!” she declares. (It’s giving “I don’t want another duke! I want this duke!”)
“This situation requires me to take a leave of my manners,” Agnes declares, her voice rising as she stomps her way across the street to have a word with Bertha.

Bertha received Agnes calmly and explains that Agnes is still the “host” of the dinner, it’s just that it will be in Bertha’s home. “And I am supposed to be pleased?” Agnes asks bewildered. Bertha explains that both the Heritage Society and the White House feel that this is what’s best. “You wrote to the President’s secretary?” Agnes asks. “No, I called the White House on our telephone!” Bertha replies. I knew that phones would get their moment on the show! Their time is now! (“I have been upended by some magical megaphone device that travels across state lines!” Agnes tells Ada as Ada drags Agnes home from the Russells’. “I told you I wanted to get a telephone,” Ada says unhelpfully. I genuinely don’t know the last time one scene of television has delighted me quite so much, every performance is better than the next.)
George comes downstairs when he hears the commotion of Agnes yelling. As the ladies of the Forte/van Rhijn household depart, George ominously tells Bertha, “You have done well with this dinner. I’m counting on you to make a success of it, you may be the key to this family’s survival.” No pressure, Bertha. No pressure.
Liz Kocan is a pop culture writer living in Massachusetts. Her biggest claim to fame is the time she won on the game show Chain Reaction.
